top of page

Do I need a bone graft before an implant?

Dr Scott Church
Nov 13
6 min read

Not always. A graft is needed when the 3D scan shows too little bone to hold an implant securely, or too little to keep it covered over the years. Bone shrinks after a tooth is removed, so the longer a gap has been there, the more likely a graft becomes. Each site is assessed and planned on its own scan.

Last reviewed 13 November 2026 by Dr Scott Church, dental surgeon, Seven Hills.

Bone graft material held in tweezers beside a platelet-rich fibrin (PRF) membrane

Why does bone go missing after a tooth is removed?

The bone around a tooth is there to hold that tooth. Once the tooth is gone, the body stops maintaining it. A systematic review of 20 studies (Tan and colleagues, Clinical Oral Implants Research, 2012) found the ridge lost between 29 and 63 per cent of its width and 11 to 22 per cent of its height in about six months.

These figures are from published reviews of many studies; individual results vary with smoking, diabetes, gum health and maintenance, and are discussed at your consultation.

Bone is the one part of an implant plan nobody can see in the mirror, which is probably why it causes the most surprise on a quote.

If you would rather know what your own scan shows than read averages, you can book a $99 consultation with me.

When can a bone graft be done?

There are four usual points, and the right one depends on the site. A plan for two teeth in the same mouth can use two different approaches.


What happens

What it is for

At the extraction

The empty socket is filled when the tooth is removed (socket preservation)

Slowing the shrinkage that follows an extraction, ahead of a later implant

With an immediate implant

The implant goes in at the same visit as the extraction, with graft material around it

Filling the space between the implant and the socket wall, where the site allows it

During implant placement

A healed site gets its implant and a graft over thin or exposed areas in one operation

Covering the implant where the ridge is a little too narrow

Before the implant, as a separate stage

The bone is rebuilt first and left to heal; the implant follows months later. A sinus lift is one example

Sites with too little bone to hold an implant at all

Should the socket be grafted every time a tooth comes out?

I think socket preservation should be considered at any extraction where an implant may follow. Considered is not the same as done: some sockets hold their shape well, and some people will never want an implant there.

The evidence is more modest than the marketing. A Cochrane review of 16 trials (Atieh and colleagues, 2021) found that grafting the socket may reduce the loss of ridge width by a little over a millimetre at six months, and rated that evidence as very uncertain. It found no good evidence yet that it reduces the need for a further graft later, or that one graft material works better than another.

Who should take the tooth out?

If an implant is likely, it often makes sense for the surgeon who will place it to do the extraction as well. How a tooth comes out affects how much of the socket wall is left, and the decision about a socket graft or an immediate implant has to be made at that visit, not afterwards.

What is a bone graft made of?

The material can be the patient's own bone, processed donor bone, an animal-derived or synthetic bone substitute, or a mix. It is usually covered with a membrane, and sometimes combined with a concentrate made from the patient's own blood (platelet-rich fibrin, or PRF). In my own cases the usual choice is bovine bone combined with PRF. What is proposed, and why, is set out in the written plan.

Why is PRF used with a graft?

PRF (platelet-rich fibrin) is made from a small sample of your own blood, taken at the appointment and spun in a centrifuge. The result is a soft membrane rich in platelets and the growth factors involved in healing, with nothing added. I use it with most grafts and extractions.

Blood collection set, two collection tubes and a centrifuge used to prepare platelet-rich fibrin (PRF)

The reason is healing. Reviews of clinical trials, most of them after wisdom tooth removal, report less pain after surgery and fewer dry sockets when PRF is used, and trials in extraction sockets report better healing of the gum and denser new bone on X-ray. The same research is clear about the limits: PRF on its own has not been shown to hold the width or height of the ridge after an extraction, and it does not replace graft material in larger defects. That is why I use it alongside donor bone and not instead of it. Many of these studies are small and of low quality, and individual results vary.

Do implants in grafted bone last as long?

A systematic review of studies with at least ten years of follow-up (Salvi and colleagues, Clinical Oral Implants Research, 2018) found no statistically significant difference in implant failure or long-term complications between implants placed in grafted bone and those placed in the patient's original bone. The authors also said the underlying studies varied a lot in design and should be read with caution. The same caveat applies: individual results vary and are discussed at your consultation.

What can go wrong with a bone graft?

A graft is surgery, and it has its own complications. In a meta-analysis of grafts done with a membrane (Lim and colleagues, International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants, 2018), about 17 in 100 had a soft-tissue complication such as the membrane becoming exposed, the wound opening or an infection. These appeared anywhere from one week to six months after surgery. A complication can mean part or all of the graft is lost and the step has to be repeated.

How much time and cost does a graft add?

A graft done at the same visit as the extraction or the implant adds little time. A staged graft adds a healing period of several months before the implant can go in. On a written quote a graft appears as its own line, so it can be seen and questioned. I have written separately about what a single tooth implant costs and what a quote should include.

Pricing is given in writing at your consultation, after your 3D scan. Interest-free payment plans are available through a third-party provider, subject to approval.

How often is a graft needed?

I end up considering a graft in about four of every five implant cases I plan. Often it is a small one done at the same visit. Sometimes the scan shows the implant can go in without any, and I say so.

Who should wait?

Grafting and implants should wait where there is active gum disease, diabetes that is not under control or heavy smoking, all of which make graft complications more likely. A tooth that can be kept should be kept. And for some people a bridge or a well-made denture is the better call, with no graft at all.

Where is this done?

I consult on Wednesdays at My Local Dentists Seven Hills, where most surgery is done. Sedation can be oral, inhalation (gas) or IV. A general anaesthetic is given at a local hospital, typically for larger procedures or where the medical history requires it, and is arranged after the consultation. Online consultations are available by appointment for people outside the area.

How do I find out whether I need one?

If you want a straight answer about your own mouth. A consultation with me is $99, credited to your treatment and refundable up to 48 hours before. It is a 3D scan where one is indicated, the options for your situation side by side, and an itemised written quote for each — in person at Seven Hills on Wednesdays, or online if you are outside the area.

or call 02 5850 2888

Sources

  • Tan WL, Wong TLT, Wong MCM, Lang NP. A systematic review of post-extractional alveolar hard and soft tissue dimensional changes in humans. Clinical Oral Implants Research 2012;23(Suppl 5):1–21. PubMed 22211303

  • Atieh MA, Alsabeeha NHM, Payne AGT, Ali S and colleagues. Interventions for replacing missing teeth: alveolar ridge preservation techniques for dental implant site development. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2021;4:CD010176. PubMed 33899930

  • Salvi GE, Monje A, Tomasi C. Long-term biological complications of dental implants placed either in pristine or in augmented sites: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical Oral Implants Research 2018;29(Suppl 16):294–310. PubMed 30328184

  • Lim G, Lin GH, Monje A, Chan HL and colleagues. Wound healing complications following guided bone regeneration for ridge augmentation: a systematic review and meta-analysis. International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants 2018;33(1):41–50. PubMed 28938030

  • Monsalves Morales N, Estrada Cáceres F, Sanchez Varela M. Platelet-rich fibrin after mandibular third molar extraction: an umbrella review of systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 2026;30(1):138. PubMed 42629517

  • Janaite L, Vasilcenko I, Cema I, Bagante I. The clinical effectiveness of platelet-rich fibrin in post-extraction healing: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Medicina 2026;62(9):1672. PubMed 42796279

  • Meneses-Santos D, Marçal AC, Mesquita CM and colleagues. Effectiveness of platelet-rich fibrin concentrates in alveolar ridge preservation after tooth extraction: a systematic review of randomized clinical trials with tomographic evaluation. Clinics 2026;81:101172. PubMed 42815352

All surgery carries risks. Whether treatment suits you is confirmed at a consultation with the surgeon. Costs are indicative until a formal quote follows clinical assessment.

Minimalist Beige Interior Designer Business Card.png
LocaTIONS

Seven Hills (book here) – My Local Dentists, Sh 55, 224 Prospect Hwy, Seven Hills NSW 2147 · Wed 12–6pm · video consults Wed 7:30–8:30pm by appointment

Local hospital · general anaesthetic surgery, arranged after consultation

Hugh Fleming Dentistry – GF, Suite 4/600 Military Rd, Mosman NSW 2088 · Tue, Thu, Fri

Grace Dental – Sh 47, 100 Bonnyrigg Ave, Bonnyrigg NSW 2177 · Mon

Follow

  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Dr Scott Church · Dental Surgeon

Individual results vary. All surgical and dental procedures carry risks; suitability is confirmed at a consultation. Any costs shown are indicative until a formal quote follows clinical assessment.

Consultations and IV-sedation surgery at Seven Hills (consulting at My Local Dentists, Seven Hills) · Hospital surgery at a local hospital · Patient and dentist enquiries: admin@drscottchurch.com · 02 5850 2888

© 2026 Dental Surgeon Group Pty Ltd (ACN 651 922 299)

bottom of page